Fair is Fair
When I was eight years old, my younger sister broke her leg while tagging along on my second grade field trip. She was in the hospital for several weeks, and then in a body cast for several more weeks. We cancelled a big family vacation, rigged up a stroller so that she could accompany us on outings, devised new and exciting ways to get her to take her medicine, and stacked up the gifts that accumulated from her many visitors.As a child, I was less than thrilled with all the attention she received! I mourned the loss of the most exciting trip we had ever planned, and watched with jealousy as she received new toys and other presents. I resented the attention she was getting from my parents and other friends and relatives, and missed the companionship of having her play with me. It just wasn’t fair!
Of course, with age comes improved perspectives and increased wisdom. I’m now able to see what I couldn’t see then with my “poor little me” attitude in the way. If anyone had a right to complain about life not being fair, it was her, not me! My parents tried to show me how unpleasant the medicine tasted, and how difficult it was for my little sister to get around while dragging her leg behind her. She probably would have gladly changed places with me!
I’ve now learned that important lesson. But as I look around me, I realize that there are still many people who have not had an opportunity to learn the difference between “fair” and “equal.” If my parents had treated us equally, they would have put a cast on me, pushed me around in stroller, and made me take disgusting medicine. Instead, they were “fair”–they gave each of us what we needed at the time. My sister got the medical treatment and necessary extra time and attention, I got the opportunity to run and play, unhindered by a broken leg or bulky cast.
Think about it. Does a child choose to have a learning disability, a form of autism, problems processing sensory input, difficulty reading, or struggles with interacting with others socially? Why do we hesitate to provide accommodations or modifications for him or her, fearing somehow that it wouldn’t be “fair” to the others in the classroom? Why do we feel it would be “unfair” for the high achievers in the classroom to do more math problems than their classmates who struggle to do even a few? Several pages of homework for one may require much less effort than a classmate’s extreme effort to complete a few problems. What’s fair? Why do we insist that it’s “only fair” for everyone to write with pen and paper, even when one child in the classroom has difficulty manipulating those tools and would do much better with a keyboard? What’s unfair about accommodating each person according to his or her needs and abilities? These are classroom examples, but questions about fairness also crop up at home, in the workplace, and in the community!
We know that life isn’t fair. Yet I believe we need to stop looking at our own perspective of how life isn’t fair for us, and look more closely at how it isn’t fair for others. As we focus on promoting social understanding, we can begin to see that people need varying degrees of time, encouragement, practice, explanations, accommodations, modifications, etc. What one person gets should not be determined according to what another person is getting, but should depend on what will help that person achieve his or her full potential.
Sound fair? Feel free to comment on this article here. And best wishes as you promote social understanding through attempting to be “fair” with those with whom you live and work!
Laurel Hoekman, Executive Director
The Gray Center for Social Learning and Understanding
P.S. Would you like help explaining differences to a child’s sibling or classmates? Check our web site for more information on books that might help, including “Brotherly Feelings,” and “Everybody is Different,” (for siblings), or “The Sixth Sense II,” “My Friend with Autism,” and “The Autism Acceptance Book” (for peers), and “The Goodenoughs Get in Sync” (to explain sensory processing difficulties). And if you have other books you’d like to see added to our bookstore, please let me know!
Comments(1)